![Just got my first whistle and found this chart. What do the plus signs beneath the second half mean and do you really remove the top finger for the second D? : Just got my first whistle and found this chart. What do the plus signs beneath the second half mean and do you really remove the top finger for the second D? :](https://preview.redd.it/just-got-my-first-whistle-and-found-this-chart-what-do-the-v0-qdia5zjizuc81.jpg?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=7a84682f9d2e05a8a4a5dc7fbdf506ce2173337f)
Just got my first whistle and found this chart. What do the plus signs beneath the second half mean and do you really remove the top finger for the second D? :
![Amazon.com: Learn to Play the Irish Tin Whistle, CD Pack (including key of D whistle, instruction book and demonstration CD) : METODO: Musical Instruments Amazon.com: Learn to Play the Irish Tin Whistle, CD Pack (including key of D whistle, instruction book and demonstration CD) : METODO: Musical Instruments](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71DD8-KDuCL.jpg)
Amazon.com: Learn to Play the Irish Tin Whistle, CD Pack (including key of D whistle, instruction book and demonstration CD) : METODO: Musical Instruments
![Nightingale Low D Whistle Alloy by Alexander Karavaev - Folkfriends - extraordinary musical instruments Nightingale Low D Whistle Alloy by Alexander Karavaev - Folkfriends - extraordinary musical instruments](https://folkfriends.com/cosmoshop/default/pix/a/n/21141-13242.jpg)